HomeJobsIt’s jobs we need
(and training) not benefits bashing

It’s jobs we need
(and training) not benefits bashing

Date:

Related stories

How many people claim sickness benefits?

About a quarter of working-aged adults in the UK...

EY UK Weighs Cutting 150 Consulting Jobs Amid Softening Demand

EY has proposed eliminating 150 consulting jobs in the...

What is Travel Tuesday – and what are the best travel deals?

Sign up to Simon Calder’s free travel email for...
spot_imgspot_img

Millions of Britons are out of work and training, will cutting benefits help the young and unemployed find jobs?(Picture: Matt Cardy/Getty Images)

Have your say on these MetroTalk topics and more in the comments.

Is Britain’s job market designed to fail?

Another day, another round of government announcements regarding people on benefits.

Works and pensions minister Liz Kendall wants to ‘get Britain working again,’ highlighting the 2.8million out of work due to long-term sickness (Metro, Wed).

And yet no one ever addresses the fundamental issue that is the lack of jobs for all those who need them.

There are 1.7million people registered as unemployed and claiming Universal Credit but only 831,000 job vacancies, according to government figures.

This leaves around one million people in the impossible position of chasing work that simply isn’t available.

And that’s to say nothing of those out of work who are not claiming benefits for whatever reason, which some reports have put as high as one million.

And then there are the 2.8million off sick or disabled that Ms Kendall wants to get back into work.

This is the great secret of our 
socio-economic system since 1979 – the oversupply of labour.

This is how wages are held down and workers kept on their toes. And the failure of the left to make mass unemployment a political issue is how the right is able to portray the situation as being due to the failure of individuals or ‘welfare dependency’ rather than a conscious policy of the economic establishment.

‘People on benefits’ have been the national whipping boy for long enough, it’s time politicians started being honest about how our labour market really works. Philip Duval, Manchester

METRO TALK – HAVE YOUR SAY

Let us know what you think…

Start a text with VIEWS followed by your comment, name and where you live to 65700. Standard network charge applies. Or email mail@ukmetro.co.uk Helpline for Views, Rush-Hour Crush and Good Deed Feed: 020 3615 0600.

Remember, you are more likely to be published if you provide your name and location with your

Full T&Cs here. Metro.co.uk is a member of the Independent Press Standards Organisation. Comments may be edited for reasons of legality, clarity or space.

To view this video please enable JavaScript, and consider upgrading to a web
browser that
supports HTML5
video

‘Provide support, not penalties’
If the government is to ‘get Britain working again’, it needs to engage students and connect them with businesses – cutting benefits for those who decline training or apprenticeships is a blunt instrument.

What they need is support, not penalties. Successive governments have failed to act, including fixing the broken Apprenticeship Levy, with apprenticeship numbers falling by 40 per cent since 2017.

Traditional education is disengaging many students. Schools struggle with absenteeism and shrinking budgets, while transport costs block access to career-focused alternatives such as University Technical Colleges (UTCs). We need systemic change – more funding for education, accessible pathways like UTCs and better support for businesses and young people alike. Penalising the disadvantaged won’t solve our skills crisis – providing opportunities will. David Land, Trustee, North East STEM Foundation Chair, UTC South Durham

Public transport cuts are holding workers back

Operations At A FirstGroup Plc Bus Depot
Not everyone can walk, bike or drive to work (Credits: Bloomberg via Getty Images)

‘How can people earn a living when bus routes are cut?’
Do ministers not understand the common sense fact that people need public transport to get to work? Without transport, they will give up their jobs or get sacked.

In Calderdale, the No.590 (the main bus on the main road from Rochdale) was cut from every half hour to every hour. This has impacted many people.

How can people get on their feet and try to earn a living when buses on main bus routes are cut like this at the coldest time of the year? Angela Walker, via email

Why affordable housing feels like a distant dream

As a lifelong resident of Walthamstow in east London, I have been watching the building of housing developments Hepworth Place and Feature 17. I was interested to see the cost of a one-bed flat in the latter was £375,000 (Metro, Tue).

How can this government hope to solve the housing crisis when developers set prices beyond the wildest dreams of most people? The government can build millions of homes – the problem is not the number of homes, but the obscene cost.

Myself and millions of other working people can only watch in despair of ever owning a home of one’s own.

Walthamstow was traditionally a working-class area, but lifelong residents now feel they are not wanted. Sharon, Walthamstow Resident

Singing at the cinema won’t make you ‘popular’ with this reader

‘I’ve paid to see the film, not listen to the audience’
Sharan Dhaliwal (Metro.co.uk) misses the point with her article demanding that we tolerate loud people during screenings of Wicked and other musical films.

If I have chosen to attend a special singalong showing that a cinema has set up, then that’s fair enough – I’ve consciously volunteered to be among like-minded people and we can hoot and holler all the way though. I’ve taken my girlfriend out to karaoke nights for the Mamma Mia! film and we always have a wonderful time.

At a general public showing, however, it’s a neutral ground and different rules apply – it should be quiet for the broadest accommodation. I’ve paid to watch a film, not a performance and I’ve paid to listen to the soundtrack, not the audience.

I shouldn’t have to accept the drowning-out of the actual movie with audience members who are, frankly, just showing off and demanding attention on themselves – my ticket was paid to the cinema, not to them!
The loudmouths are being obnoxious and anti-social. Robert Frazer, Salford

Why dangerous drivers deserve tougher sentences

Catherine Davies after George Taylor hit her with his car (Picture: Norfolk Constabulary/SWNS)

‘A two-year sentence isn’t enough for ruining a life’
I’ve just read about the car crash that paralysed Catherine Davies from the neck down (Metro, Wed). Driver George Taylor, 19, was filming himself steering with his knees when he hit her.

He should get more than the two years in jail he was sentenced and banned from driving permanently, not just 40 months. He will end up behind a steering wheel again and his memory of how he wrecked this poor woman’s life will fade. William Barklam, Erith

Taiwan, Tibet and the lies of modern imperialism

‘Claiming Taiwan is no different from Russia claiming Ukraine’
Robert Bucknor (MetroTalk, Mon) makes the surprising assertion that Tibet and Taiwan are an integral part of China and also that Northern Ireland endured a ‘civil war’ in the recent past.

He makes the first claim to warn against meddling in the affairs of Beijing and the second as part of his argument that we would not have welcomed other countries meddling in ours.

Neither are true. Tibet was conquered by revolutionary China in a violent invasion in the 1950s, reminiscent of Russia’s attack on Poland after the 1917 revolution.

Taiwan was the last hold out of the defeated nationalists in the Chinese civil war and never part of the Chinese communist party’s domain.

To make a claim on territory that the indigenous population rejects is old-fashioned imperialism and to swallow Chinese propaganda about Taiwan is the same as assuming Russia has a ‘claim’ to Ukraine. Both views amount to little more than appeasement of fascist countries intent on dominating Asia and Europe.

Sticking up for democratic, western-supporting countries and indeed individuals is not ‘interference in the internal affairs’ of Russia or China but instead showing support for peoples who reject a fascist future.
Northern Ireland did not endure a civil war, that took place further south in the 1920s. Instead there was a violent insurgency and brutal tribal conflict, which was eventually resolved with significant American input. Chris Shepherd, London

- Never miss a story with notifications

- Gain full access to our premium content

- Browse free from up to 5 devices at once

Latest stories

spot_img